17/03/2021
How did 5,000 salary claims a year become 1,400 over five years? – TWC2
about two to 6.5 months, compared with the
0.5 to 2 months for locals.
Although the news story as a whole seemed to be reporting on
the Employment Standards Report 2017-2018, your writer has
not been able to nd mention of this in the original report itself,
so it is unclear where Channel NewsAsia got its information.
Success rate and restitution?
The Employment Standards Reports do not present enough
numbers about success rate and restitution, nor any split
between local and foreign employees on this score.
Instead, paragraph 9 on page 5 of the Employment Standards
Report 2019-2020 says this:
Of the salary claims lodged between 1 January
2019 and 30 June 2020, 90% of employees
successfully recovered their salaries fully at
TADM or the Employment Claims Tribunals
(ECT). About half of the remaining employees
partially recovered their salaries. The total
recovered sum amounted to about $23 million.
(emphasis added by TWC2)
And still we have questions!
Believe it or not, we don’t even know what “successfully
recovered… fully” means. At TWC2, we come across many
cases like these:
1. Reduction in claim amount under pressure
Example: a worker has been shortpaid $8,000 under
various headings (basic salary, overtime, public holiday
pay, annual leave equivalent, unfair deductions, etc). At
the TADM mediation stage, he comes under pressure to
jettison parts of his claim because the evidence he has is
not very strong (e.g. employer refused to produce time
cards that would prove his claim). He is pressured to
reduce his claim amount to, say, $4,100. A settlement
twc2.org.sg/2021/03/08/how-did-5000-salary-claims-a-year-become-1400-over-five-years/?fbclid=IwAR3ndC6fHNpfjRFmcV9VKV2f4_D0-B5MyB…
6/8